Long March 2D launch · Long March 2DLiftoff in Nov 18, around 22:00 UTCDetails ›
Hot Space News

Webb galaxy spin study: 158 clockwise, 105 counterclockwise, no agreed cause

A Kansas State study of 263 spiral galaxies in a JWST deep field found more rotate clockwise than counterclockwise, but independent work disputes a cosmic spin bias and no cause is established.

Webb galaxy spin study: 158 clockwise, 105 counterclockwise, no agreed cause

A 2025 study of 263 spiral galaxies in a James Webb Space Telescope deep field found that 158 rotate clockwise and 105 counterclockwise. Its author says the cause is unknown; independent analyses of galaxy spins dispute any large-scale bias.

What the Kansas State study counted

The work comes from Lior Shamir, an associate professor of computer science at Kansas State University. The university announced it on March 12, 2025, and it was accepted by Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (DOI 10.1093/mnras/staf292). The preprint, posted to arXiv on February 26, 2025, is titled “The distribution of galaxy rotation in JWST Advanced Deep Extragalactic Survey”.

Graphic of a JWST starfield of spiral galaxies with red and blue circles marking opposite rotation directions relative to the Milky Way
Image: Kansas State University

The data come from the GOODS-South field of the JWST Advanced Deep Extragalactic Survey, known as JADES. According to the paper, Shamir used images from Webb’s NIRCam, its near-infrared camera, in three infrared bands combined into color images. Only galaxies whose spiral arms allowed a spin direction to be assigned were kept. That left 263 galaxies: 105 turning counterclockwise, the same sense as the Milky Way, and 158 turning clockwise. The paper describes this as about 50% more clockwise galaxies. K-State summarizes it as roughly two-thirds clockwise and one-third counterclockwise.

How spin direction was measured

The classification was done by a computer program, not by eye. The paper says the Ganalyzer algorithm separates each galaxy from the background, converts it to a radial intensity plot, finds the arm pixels and fits their slope to decide which way the arms curve. Galaxies with unclear arms stay unclassified, and ellipticals, smooth galaxies with no spiral arms, are excluded. As a check, the whole field was mirrored and reanalyzed, and the results flipped exactly, as expected for a method with no built-in preference.

Webb's First Deep Field: galaxy cluster SMACS 0723 and lensed background galaxies in infrared light
Image: NASA, ESA, CSA, and STScI

The paper gives a one-tailed binomial probability of about 0.0007 for an imbalance this large arising by chance in an even split, equal to about 3.39 sigma, a standard measure of how far a result sits from pure chance. That is below the 5 sigma level usually required in particle physics for a discovery claim.

Two explanations and neither settled

Shamir offers two possibilities. In the K-State release he said: “It is still not clear what causes this to happen.” One explanation is that “the universe was born rotating”, which he links to black hole cosmology, the idea that the universe is the interior of a black hole. He says that, if true, current cosmological theories would be incomplete.

The other is an observational effect. Because of the Doppler shift, galaxies rotating opposite to the Milky Way may look slightly brighter and so be easier to detect. The paper itself notes that the effect should be mild and that rotation speeds alone would not obviously account for a difference of about 50%. If the effect were real and larger than expected, Shamir says, distance measurements for the deep universe would need recalibrating. The paper and release also suggest links to the Hubble tension, the mismatch between measured expansion rates, and to massive galaxies seen very early. These are presented as possibilities, not findings.

Why a cosmic spin bias remains contested

The result is a count in one patch of sky, and the paper lists its limits: a single field, one classification algorithm, and a sample restricted to galaxies with clear arms. Cosmic variance, the chance that one patch of sky is not representative of the whole, and selection effects are not fully assessed. The paper also compares the field with earlier data: a preliminary JWST field analysis found 23 clockwise among 33 galaxies (p about 0.012), while Webb’s First Deep Field showed no significant asymmetry, with 21 counterclockwise and 19 clockwise.

Other researchers have tested the wider claim and reached a different conclusion. Dhruva Patel and Harry Desmond, in a paper published in MNRAS 534(2), compiled public datasets of galaxy spin classifications and tested for dipole-like and hemisphere patterns with Bayesian and frequentist methods. They found the data consistent with isotropy, meaning no preferred direction, to within 3 sigma, and they attribute earlier claims of anisotropy to biased or ad hoc statistics. That analysis concerns other surveys, not the JADES field, so the two results are not a direct contradiction, but they show the broader claim has not been accepted.

A decisive test would need independent classifications, ideally with different methods, across several well-separated sky regions. Kansas State University’s page on the study, updated in February 2026, reports no such confirmation.

Why the black hole idea goes beyond the data

The data do not show that the universe sits inside a black hole. The paper treats the cosmological, galaxy-physics and observational readings as unresolved. A bias in 263 galaxies of one field, at about 3.39 sigma and with independent analyses of other datasets finding isotropy, is not enough to rule out chance or a measurement effect. Until other teams reproduce the count in other fields, the result is best read as an open anomaly in one deep field.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like