Amazon Leo · Ariane 64 Block 2Liftoff in Nov 23, 11:09 UTCWatch live ›
Hot Space News

Claim of a 26.7-billion-year-old universe stays outside the mainstream

A single-author 2023 paper proposed an age of 26.7 billion years, but NASA still gives 13.8 billion and says Webb's early galaxies have not contradicted current models.

Claim of a 26.7-billion-year-old universe stays outside the mainstream

NASA still puts the age of the universe at 13.8 billion years. A 2023 paper by Rajendra Gupta proposed 26.7 billion years instead, but the figure comes from one author’s alternative model and has not been adopted.

Where the 26.7 billion figure comes from

The figure appeared in “JWST early Universe observations and ΛCDM cosmology”, published in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (volume 524, pages 3385-3395, 2023). The preprint was submitted to arXiv on September 22, 2023. Earlier versions of this story on spaceandsky.com cited Physical Review D, a journal the paper does not appear in, and that error is corrected here.

Image: NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI, Steve Finkelstein (UT Austin), Micaela Bagley (UT Austin), Rebecca Larson (UT Austin)

Gupta starts from the James Webb Space Telescope’s early galaxies. He writes that galaxies at a redshift of about 15 (redshift measures how much the expansion of space has stretched light, and a higher value means a more distant, earlier time), roughly 0.3 billion years after the Big Bang, look as evolved as galaxies that have existed for about 10 billion years. He argues this is in strong tension with the standard ΛCDM model, the mainstream description of the universe’s makeup and expansion.

His proposed fix is a hybrid. It combines a covarying coupling constants model, in which physical constants change over time, with “tired light,” the old idea that light loses energy on its journey for reasons other than cosmic expansion. By the paper’s own account, a tired-light model alone fails on the isotropy of the cosmic microwave background and on supernova distances. The combined model, Gupta reports, fits the Pantheon+ supernova data and is consistent with the Webb observations. In it the universe is 26.7 billion years old, with 5.8 billion years elapsed at redshift 10 and 3.5 billion years at redshift 20.

Image: NASA, ESA, H. Bond (STScI and Penn State), E. Nelan (STScI), D. VandenBerg (University of Victoria), G. Schaefer (CHARA, Mt. Wilson Observatory), D. Harmer (NOAO); Digitized Sky Survey (DSS), STScI/AURA, Palomar/Caltech, UKSTU/AAO

What NASA says Webb has and has not shown

Webb’s early galaxies are real, and some were more massive or brighter than expected. NASA’s Webb explainer addresses the age question directly in a section titled “Webb has not disproved the big bang theory.” It says some of the telescope’s earliest findings suggested large galaxies in the early universe, which led some to argue that the accepted age of the universe was wrong. After follow-up studies and comparisons with simulations, the claims were judged overblown. Macarena Garcia Marin, Webb project scientist at the Space Telescope Science Institute, said the new observations raise questions but “they have not contradicted our current best models.”

The puzzle Webb poses is about how quickly galaxies and stars formed, not about the clock itself. A faster-than-expected galaxy build-up is a problem for galaxy-formation models, and astronomers can address it by adjusting those models without changing the age of the cosmos.

Image: NASA

The Methuselah star no longer outlives the universe

The old story leaned on HD 140283, nicknamed the Methuselah star, which is about 190 light-years away in Libra. In 2013, NASA reported that Hubble measurements gave it an age of 14.5 billion years, with an uncertainty of 0.8 billion years. The central value exceeded the universe’s age, but NASA noted that the refined estimate brought the star’s age range into overlap with 13.8 billion years.

Later work has pushed the star’s age down. A 2024 study in Astronomy & Astrophysics, posted to arXiv in November 2024, used stellar models with tailored chemical abundances and found about 12.3 billion years. A solar-scaled mixture gave about 14 billion years, which the authors describe as in conflict with the universe’s age of 13.77 plus or minus 0.06 billion years. The age of the Methuselah star therefore depends on modeling choices, and the better-fitting models give an age well below that of the universe.

Independent measurements and what is still uncertain

The standard age rests largely on measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the faint afterglow of the Big Bang. The final data release of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT), described in arXiv:2503.14452 and accepted by the Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, found that ΛCDM fits its temperature and polarization spectra across 19,000 square degrees of sky. Combined with Planck data, CMB lensing and DESI baryon acoustic oscillation data, it gives a Hubble constant of 68.22 plus or minus 0.36 kilometers per second per megaparsec. Adding DESI’s second data release gives 68.43 plus or minus 0.27. The paper’s abstract does not state an age.

Real uncertainty remains elsewhere. The Hubble constant measured from the early universe differs from values measured in the nearby universe, and the origin of the bright early galaxies is still being worked out. Those open questions concern how fast the universe expands and how galaxies grew. They do not currently point to a universe twice as old.

Gupta’s model is also a single-author proposal that has not been confirmed independently, and its age depends on assumptions, such as changing physical constants, that the standard model does not make. Until observations favor those assumptions over the simpler ones, 13.8 billion years remains the age given by NASA.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

Exit mobile version